Download Law and Logic: A Critical Account of Legal Argument by Joseph Horovitz PDF

By Joseph Horovitz

This booklet has comparable goals: to enquire the usually voiced declare that felony argument is nonformal in nature and, in the limits of such an research, to check the main common right­ ties of legislations as a rational procedure. exam of a few perspectives of criminal argument, chosen from fresh discussions in Germany, Belgium, and the English-speaking nations, will bring about the stick with­ ing major conclusions. The nonformalistic conceptions of the good judgment of felony argument are ambiguous and uncertain. in addition, insofar as those conceptions are able to explanation within the mild of contemporary analytical technique, they are often noticeable to be both wrong otherwise appropriate with the formalistic place. simply because legislations is socially directive and coordinative, it really is based upon theoretical psycho­ sociology and calls, in precept, for a deontic and inductive common sense. the first functionality of felony argument is to supply carrying on with reinterpretation and affirmation of criminal principles, conceived as theo­ retical prescriptions. at the foundation of this belief, the outdated juris­ prudential clash among formalism and rule-scepticism seems to be considerably resolved. Aristotle, the founding father of the speculation of argument, conceived it as "the technology of creating conclusions" (bnO'l;~fl'YJ &no~e!"u,,~), designed to lead humans in rational argumentation. In time, how­ ever, good judgment forsook its useful functionality and built as a hugely summary and disinterested learn, this present day known as "formal logic"; and the idea of sensible argument used to be both ignored or relegated to an appendix to rhetoric.

Show description

Read Online or Download Law and Logic: A Critical Account of Legal Argument PDF

Similar law books

Lives of Lawyers Revisited: Transformation and Resilience in the Organizations of Practice (Law, Meaning, and Violence)

The prior twenty years have noticeable profound adjustments within the criminal career. Lives of legal professionals Revisited extends Michael Kelly’s paintings within the unique Lives of legal professionals, providing targeted insights into the character of those alterations, tested via tales of 5 terribly assorted legislations practices. by way of putting the highlight on enterprises as phenomena that generate their very own good judgment and tensions, Lives of legal professionals Revisited speaks to the event of many attorneys and anticipates very important concerns at the expert horizon.

Company Law, 2nd Edition (Longman Law Series)

The second one version of this well known publication on corporation legislations combines theoretical and jurisprudential concerns with an updated account of criminal advancements around the box of corporation legislations. the writer demonstrates that the desires of shareholders in businesses that have dispersed possession of stocks can't be appropriately understood with out an research of the legislation when it comes to securities rules and capital markets.

Law and Semiotics: Volume 2

Of these difficulties in legislations which we inherit and/or retrieve which will reconstruct and interpret within the gentle of felony semiotics, in spite of the fact that outlined. as well as 3 major components of underlying metaphysical assumptions there also are 3 major parts of attainable editorial concentration and those may be pointed out.

Additional resources for Law and Logic: A Critical Account of Legal Argument

Sample text

It is sufficient to interpret the original rules as applicable not only to contracts of sale in the narrow sense, but also to contracts which are contracts-of-sale-or-contracts-similar-to-contracts-of-sale ("similar" to be read as "similar in all essential respects", thus also subsequently in every suitable context), since contracts of transfer of a commercial establishment are similar to contracts of sale. In the form given above: S, contracts of transfer of a commercial establishment; P, contracts to which the original rule is applicable; M, contracts of sale; N, contracts similar to contracts of sale.

However, this analogy is deficient in an important respect: while scientific observations are intersubjective and fairly stable (though dependent on methods of observation and measurement which develop with the passage of time), substantial differences exist between the volitions of the members of a society, and these volitions are greatly affected by social change. The problem of the criteria for adequate confirmation, thus, is far more complex in law than in science. One cannot escape serious consideration of the question of whose volitions are decisive in legal confirmation.

Such an examination necessitates a clear distinction between the factual affirmation of the state of contemporary law and the question concerning the possibilities of its development and formalization. It also necessitates a distinction between obstacles in practice and obstacles in principle that stand in the way of the rationalization of adjudication. A legal system is constructed in order to allow adjudication by logical means. As long as the system is not sufficiently developed, such possibilities are in themselves limited.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.75 of 5 – based on 36 votes